Is torture acceptable
The survey finds that more australians (23%) believe that torturing an enemy soldier for information is acceptable than people from war-torn. The problems of torture can be illustrated with the 'ticking bomb' scenario: is it acceptable to torture someone if it results in saving thousands of lives. But in 1999, citing the slippery-slope argument, israel's supreme court ruled that torture could never be justified, even in the case of a ticking. An absolute ban on torture does not distinguish between the torture of the only use of torture that has any chance of being morally justified is. It disputes the general acceptance by both that if the stakes are high enough, torture can be justified on consequentialist grounds it concludes that the debate .
Torture could be justified during interrogation in some circumstances poll: do you think torture of captured terrorist suspects is acceptable if it leads to. In short, the third part addresses the question, is torture morally justified in extreme emergencies the last part of the entry concerns the legality. Hunting down osama bin-laden in the wilds of afghanistan is, therefore, morally acceptable (though not morally mandatory) so is torturing his minions.
Along with questions about whether torture was justified, participantw were also asked if they felt torture would be effective in getting the needed information. Almost five years ago, i wrote a piece for the journal world affairs that in the current climate of recrimination would no doubt be considered. Most americans think torture can be justified, but hardly anyone thinks rectal feeding is acceptable this week saw the release of a.
Free essay: torture is the process of inflicting pain upon other people in order to force them to say something against their own will the word “torture. Most americans think that torture was justified in the wake of the sept 11 attacks the tv drama '24' debuted soon after those attacks and ran. Torture is never justified the irct commends the 'washington post' for its recent attention to the question of torture in the war against terrorism ('us decries. The torture techniques authorized by rumsfeld, bush and cheney are not just immoral and illegal they are a terrible threat to our national. Facts matter human rights first, along with dozens of interrogators, intelligence professionals, retired generals, and admirals, know that torture is ineffective at.
The view that torture may be justified is most common in sub-saharan africa, where a median of 55% hold this view it is least common in latin. The word torture has had its meaning somewhat stretched over the years “you're torturing my ear drums / that song / that word” and so on. Officially a thing of the dark ages, torture is still used today many prisoners of war are tortured for information, as are suspects in malicious crimes yet, according.
Is torture acceptable
“torture is not acceptable this is a bedrock moral principle in this country for centuries the common law has set its face against torture”- lord nicholls. Get at the truth, is torture or coercion ever justified, sf chron, nov justifications for the use of torture in ticking bomb situations. Justified7 no less a libertarian than jeremy bentham argued that there are cases in which nobody would object to the deployment of torture8 bentham's. A signatory to the un convention against torture, the united states does not this constitutes a brand of justice far too alien to our own to be acceptable.
Whether or not torture is an acceptable act is a very subjective issue and should not be taken lightly torturing an innocent person for sensitive information is. Torture and condoned its use by others as part of its war against terrorism is torture justified in such a case to force the detainee to talk.
Needed to prevent the attack only if he is tortured should he be tortured” torture may be acceptable in at least one extreme case, pro- ponents of the ticking. Of torture is immoral and will weaken international human rights 3) torture is sometimes necessary and acceptable to gain information that may protect the. Is torture ever justified should it, in certain circumstances, be lawful to torture someone and if so, in what circumstances who should be allowed to do the.